Penn State’s Saquon Barkley is the best player in this draft. Should Cleveland take him with the first overall pick?
By: Elias McMillan
It’s draft week and it is finally time for me to unveil my mock draft. Mock drafts can be classified as mostly pointless. Probably because we are overly saturated with them from the moment football season ends. I realized this and I ask myself, “How can I make my mock draft even more pointless?” This is how I arrived at the idea of doing my first mock draft with trades. Now, I’ll have selections and trade scenarios that probably will not happened. With that being said, (once again) the Cleveland Browns are on the clock…..
1. Cleveland Browns – Sam Darnold, QB, USC: Cleveland has the first overall pick again this year and this time, they will not pass on a QB. With that decision, they are risking missing out of the best player in the draft. But they do have enough assets to maybe trade up to the very next pick. With this selection, the Browns will give themselves a potential QB of the future to groom behind Tyrod Taylor. Sam Darnold will be the first QB taken in the draft for the same reason why Mitch Trubisky went at number two last year: potential. Darnold may not be ready to play right away but he has the potential to be a top QB in the league. There are QB’s in this draft that may have a better arm and may be more athletically gifted than Darnold, but he is play maker. We can’t get too wrapped up around arm strength. Darnold can get the ball out to his playmakers as well as any QB in this draft.
((((TRADE)))) Giants trade second overall pick and 4th rounder (108) to Bills for 12th overall pick, 22nd overall, 2nd round pick (56), and a 2019 1st round pick
2. Buffalo Bills – Josh Rosen, QB, UCLA: After dumping Tyrod Taylor to Cleveland, Buffalo needs to make the big move up to grab a franchise QB. The Giants could very well take a QB or the best player available here. But they seem to be committed to Eli Manning for one more year (for some reason) and I think the Bills will give the Giants an offer that they can’t refuse. It would be funny if the Giants said no to THREE first rounders just to draft a running back but I don’t see that happening. The Giants will gain future assets with the haul from Buffalo and the Bills will get a QB in Rosen who is the most pro ready out of this draft class.
3. New York Jets – Baker Mayfield, QB, Oklahoma: The Jets traded up with the Colts to take a QB and I have them taking the Heisman winner out of Oklahoma. Baker Mayfield has been a lightning rod for discussion for some reason during this draft process. I think Mayfield has plenty of question marks from his hype and his attitude but I think he is a good player. My issue with him is that he has most likely peaked already as a QB. Mayfield was a walk-on at a D-1 program and ended up winning the Heisman at one of the most storied programs in college football. Its an amazing story. For him to be successful at the next level, I think he needs time to soak up information in a veteran heavy locker room in order to humble himself. The Jets already have a couple of vets at the position so, Mayfield will have plenty of time to study up and later prove himself.
4. Cleveland Browns – Saquon Barkley, RB, Penn State: This is the dream scenario if your Cleveland. You take a risk with drafting a QB first overall but then the best player in the draft is still available at the fourth pick. I have been a long time supporter of NOT drafting a running back in the top 10 of the draft but I’m willing to ignore that this time because of the team involved. My thing is that team’s that regularly compete for championships usually do not draft RB’s early. Well, Cleveland isn’t competing for championships anytime soon. They just need to best talent. I think Barkley was better at Penn State than Ezekiel Elliott and Leonard Fournette were in college. Barkley has everything you would want at the RB position and he would join a talented RB group in Cleveland, which will be key for keeping him fresh. Barkley could totally transform the Browns offense and the league, as he reminds me of the second coming of Marshall Faulk.
5. Denver Broncos – Josh Allen, QB, Wyoming: I don’t believe that John Elway is ready to roll with Case Keenum. I’m not a big fan of Josh Allen but I know that he’ll probably end up going after Mayfield in the draft. Allen has the strongest arm in the draft and is sort of athletic, so the scouts absolutely love him. I feel like QB’s like him always look the part during the process getting to the draft but then they end up not panning out. I can see Denver falling for this in this draft.
6. Indianapolis Colts – Bradley Chubb, DE, NC State: The Colts, who traded back, will end the run on QB’s. Bradley Chubb is the best pass rusher in this draft. Chubb isn’t as dynamic as an athlete as last year’s number one pick, Myles Garrett. But he is still really good and the Colts sack totals as a team last season ranked among the bottom in the league. They could absolutely use his talents.
7. Tampa Bay Buccaneers – Minkah Fitzpatrick, S/CB, Alabama: Minkah Fitzpatrick is one of the most versatile players in this draft. Tampa could use him as a ball hawk safety or as a pass defender in nickel situations. Fitzpatrick has a knack for making plays around the football and thats something that the Bucs defense could use. Their pass defense ranked last in the league in 2017.
8. Chicago Bears – Tremaine Edmunds, LB, Virginia Tech: The Bears need a new inside presence at linebacker. Edmunds looks like he could play for the Bulls. He is crazy athletic but plays with a certain physicality that will make him popular with Chicago fans.
((((TRADE)))) 49ers trade ninth overall pick to Giants for 12th overall pick and 2nd round pick (34).
9. New York Giants – Quentin Nelson, OG, Notre Dame: After trading out of the top ten, the Giants return to help their offensive line. Nelson is regarded as the best offensive lineman in the draft and drafting him could go a long ways in helping the Giants run game improve.
10. Oakland Raiders – Roquan Smith, LB, Georgia: Roquan Smith is probably the best LB in the draft and rumor has it that Jon Gruden really likes him. Smith could probably go higher than 10 but there are some whispers about injury concerns. But if healthy, Smith will be a do-it-all defender in the middle of the Raiders defense for years to come.
11. Miami Dolphins – Da’Ron Payne, DT, Alabama: The Dolphins need a Ndamukong Suh replacement. Payne is a disruptor that would shine in Miami’s 4-3 scheme.
12. San Francisco 49ers – Denzel Ward, CB, Ohio State: The Niners will land the best corner in the draft. Ward is a short but scrappy defender. He offers great speed and quickness while supplying ideal support in the run game as a tackler. Richard Sherman will serve as a great mentor for him.
13. Washington – Vita Vea, DT, Washington: Washington had the worst run defense in the league last season despite having one of the better defensive tackles dropping to them in the first round of last year’s draft. Vita Vea is an absolute load that will demand plenty of attention from opposing offensive lineman.
14. Green Bay Packers – Marcus Davenport, OLB/DE, UTSA: I think the Packers will think hard about taking a WR here but I also think they need to start thinking about life after Clay Matthews. I have them taking Marcus Davenport. He’s a small school product but is one of the best edge defenders in this draft.
Lamar Jackson probably should be drafted in the top ten.
15. Arizona Cardinals – Lamar Jackson, QB, Louisville: I don’t like the way Arizona handled their QB situation during this offseason. Placing your faith in Sam Bradford and Mike Glennon doesn’t really inspire much confidence. But it does tell me that they need to think about taking a QB for the future. Lamar Jackson is as talented as any QB in this draft. There are question marks about his durability, his arm, and his talent as a passer. But you could easily say the same about every QB in this draft. Jackson may have to prove himself as a passer early in his career but he has one thing that is undeniable in his wheelhouse: speed. Jackson has “home run” capable speed in his arsenal, which will make him attractive to NFL teams. I think Arizona would be smart to take a chance with this kid who won the Heisman as a junior in college.
16. Baltimore Ravens – Mike McGlinchey, OT, Notre Dame: Baltimore could go a lot of ways with this selection. I chose for them to play it safe and shore up the right side of their offensive line. The Ravens could potentially take Joe Flacco’s successor here or a new weapon in the passing game. But, an offensive tackle to help that offense isn’t a bad idea.
17. Los Angeles Chargers – Derwin James, S, Florida State: This will probably be consider a steal in most draft circles. Derwin James is a “do-it-all” defender in the secondary. I question how high his ceiling is as he doesn’t seem like a great pass defender but more of a “in-the-box” safety. But his athleticism and physicality will help him become very successful no matter the role he finds in the secondary.
18. Seattle Seahawks – Josh Jackson, CB, Iowa: Richard Sherman is gone. The Legion of Boom is going under a face lift and a corner here would make a ton of sense.
((((TRADE)))) Cowboys trade 19th overall pick and 4th round pick (116) to Patriots for 23rd overall pick and 2nd round pick (63).
19. New England Patriots – Kolton Miller, OT, UCLA: The Patriots desperately need a replacement for Nate Solder on the offensive line. So, they’ll trade up with Dallas to grab the next best tackle. Kolton Miller will remain Patriots fans of Solder with how tall he is and hopefully with his play. New England will need Miller to play at a high level right away especially for an older QB.
20. Detroit Lions – Maurice Hurst, DT, Michigan: The Lions are looking for youth on the defensive line. Hurst, from near by Ann Arbor, is undersized but very talented as a pass rusher.
21. Cincinnati Bengals – James Daniels, C, Iowa: Cincinnati’s running game has suffered in the last couple seasons. They need to shore up the interior of their offensive line to help Joe Mixon and Gio Bernard.
22. New York Giants – Harold Landry, DE, Boston College: After trading away Jason Pierre Paul, the Giants are in need for pass rushers. Landry has been one of the top pass rushers in college football during the last two seasons. He will fill a need for the Giants who have this selection due to a trade earlier with Buffalo.
23. Dallas Cowboys – Will Hernandez, OG, UTEP: Dallas could easily go with a WR or LB in the first round. But I think the Dez Bryant release taught us that they will depend heavily on the run game going forward now more than ever. Dallas can solidify the left guard position by drafting Hernandez who is an absolute mauler.
24. Carolina Panthers – Calvin Ridley, WR, Alabama: Cam Newton would love this selection. Ridley is the first WR off the board but he will probably go before the 24th pick. Ridley offers great speed and elite route running but he isn’t your prototypical Alabama receiver. He isn’t as physically gifted as Julio Jones and he is more like a lesser version of Amari Cooper. Ridley is a good player and he could be a good pro but he doesn’t have that “wow” factor like WR’s in past drafts.
25. Tennessee Titans – Leighton Vader Esch, LB, Boise State: Vader Esch is another player who might go closer to the middle of the first round despite rumors about his health. He is a good down hill tackler as a LB and he would provide some much needed depth at the position for Tennessee.
26. Atlanta Falcons – Taven Bryan, DT, Florida: Florida’s Taven Bryan will offer some versatility on the Falcons defensive line. He is big enough to play inside and is athletic enough to rush from the outside. He is raw as a football player and he may be a project before becoming a full time contributor.
27. New Orleans Saints – Hayden Hurst, TE, South Carolina: The Saints get Drew Brees the top TE in the draft. Hurst, a former baseball player, could help create some mismatches with his height.
With the Ryan Shazier injury, Pittsburgh could really use a LB like Rashaan Evans
28. Pittsburgh Steelers – Rashaan Evans, LB, Alabama: Pittsburgh needs LB help with the status of Ryan Shazier in the air. Taking a Alabama LB has proven to be risky recently outside of Baltimore’s CJ Mosley. But Evans is among one the most talented players at the position in the draft. I think he is undersized but in a 3-4 scheme, Pittsburgh could use him in the middle or as a situational pass rusher.
29. Jacksonville Jaguars – D.J. Moore, WR, Maryland: Moore is probably my favorite WR in this draft. Moore is a quick, tough, playmaker who reminds me of another Maryland receiver: Stephon Diggs. Jacksonville should be looking for a WR after losing Allen Robinson in free agency.
30. Minnesota Vikings – Isaiah Wynn, OG, Georgia: Minnesota is excited about Kirk Cousins but they should really be excited about the return of Dalvin Cook who missed most of last season due to injury. With a healthy Cook and this selection of a young, upcoming guard, Minnesota could have a really strong running game.
31. New England Patriots – Carlton Davis, CB, Auburn: New England’s secondary has been a joke for a while now. They need help.
32. Philadelphia Eagles – Jaire Alexander, CB, Louisville: Philadelphia’s secondary isn’t that much better than New England’s. Jaire Alexander is a playmaker who does his most damage as a returner, usually after interceptions.
33. Cleveland Browns – Harrison Phillips, DT, Stanford: Cleveland can address their run defense with this selection.
34. San Francisco 49ers – Justin Reid, S, Stanford: San Francisco moved on from Eric Reid so they’ll draft his little brother from nearby Stanford here.
35. Cleveland Browns – Brian O’Neill, OT, Pittsburgh: Joe Thomas retired this offseason. The Browns need young bodies on that offensive line.
36. Indianapolis Colts – Derrius Guice, RB, LSU: Frank Gore left to go home to Miami. Indy desperately needs a young RB.
37. Indianapolis Colts – Mike Hughes, CB, Central Florida: The Colts have two straight selections in round two. With the second one, they’ll take a corner to replace Vontae Davis who was traded away to Buffalo.
38. Tampa Bay Buccaneers – Sony Michel, RB, Georgia: Sony Michel has shot up draft boards during this process. He was considered the “second banana” in the backfield while at Georgia but he helped form one of the better RB duos in CFB. Michel isn’t the fastest RB but he can get tough yards and prove to be valuable on passing downs.
39. Chicago Bears – Isaiah Oliver, CB, Colorado: You can never have enough corners.
40. Denver Broncos – Ronald Jones, RB, USC: Denver recently cut C.J. Anderson and that created a need at RB.
41. Oakland Raiders – Joseph Noteboom, OT, TCU: Oakland needs depth behind Donald Penn at tackle.
42. Miami Dolphins – Mike Gesicki, TE, Penn State: This could be the steal of the draft. Gesicki has the ideal size and speed that team’s would want at TE. Miami needs a target at TE after the disaster that was Julius Thomas.
New England needs to find a possible Brady successor in round two. Oklahoma State’s Mason Rudolph could be it.
43. New England Patriots – Mason Rudolph, QB, Oklahoma State: The Patriots got rid of three different Tom Brady backups in the past two years. Rudolph would make a lot of sense here.
44. Washington – Donte Jackson, CB, LSU: Washington doesn’t have much at corner behind Norman and newly acquired Orlando Scandrick.
45. Green Bay Packers – Christian Kirk, WR, Texas A&M: Kirk will prove to be a great receiver in the slot for Aaron Rodgers.
46. Cincinnati Bengals – Darius Leonard, OLB, South Carolina State: The Bengals need to start grooming a replacement for the problematic Vontaze Burfict at LB. Leonard is a small school product but offers much athleticism.
47. Arizona Cardinals – Orlando Brown, OT, Oklahoma: Arizona had one of the worst offensive line last season. They need to explore a way to upgrade that unit for no matter who is starting at QB.
48. Los Angeles Chargers – Tim Settle, DT, Virginia Tech: The Chargers need to get younger on the defensive line. Tim Settle is one of the biggest defensive tackles in the draft and he’ll help improve LA’s run defense.
49.Indianapolis Colts – Connor Williams, OG/OT, Texas: The Colts could use a young blocker to help improve their run game. Conor Williams could play at tackle or move inside to guard.
After the release of Dez Bryant, Dallas might not have to look far for WR help.
50. Dallas Cowboys – Courtland Sutton, WR, SMU: Dallas created a need at WR when they released Dez Bryant last week. Courtland Sutton is a local kid who would love the chance to become an outside threat for Dak Prescott in the passing game. Sutton isn’t a speedster but his size makes it hard for defenders to deal with. He could develop as a new jump ball target in the red zone for Dallas.
51. Detroit Lions – Billy Price, OG/C, Ohio State: The Lions need help at improving one of the worst running games in football from a season ago. The selection of Price would address the woes on the interior of Detroit’s offensive line.
52. Baltimore Ravens – Tegray Scales, LB, Indiana: Baltimore needs depth at LB behind all-pro C.J. Mosley.
53. Buffalo Bills – Anthony Miller, WR, Memphis: Miller could develop into an ideal slot receiver as a pro.
Arden Key was a pass rush specialist at LSU
54. Kansas City Chiefs – Arden Key, OLB, LSU: After the departure of Tamba Hali, the Chiefs need to find younger pass rushers. Key is undersized but could excel as an outside rusher in a 3-4 defense.
55. Carolina Panthers – Ronnie Harrison, S, Alabama: Carolina needs help in the secondary after addressing the offensive side of the ball earlier.
56. New York Giants – Nick Chubb, RB, Georgia: Chubb might have a lot of milage on him but he was one of the most talented backs in college football during his time at Georgia.
57. Tennessee Titans – Lorenzo Carter, OLB, Georgia: Tennessee can use Carter for depth behind veterans Brian Orakpo and Derrick Morgan.
58. Atlanta Falcons – Dallas Goedert, TE, South Dakota State: Atlanta never get enough out of the TE position. They need an upgrade.
59. San Francisco 49ers – Austin Corbett, OG, Nevada: This pick would be for depth for recently signed Jonathan Cooper.
60. Pittsburgh Steelers – Will Richardson, OT, NC State: Pittsburgh’s offensive line is pretty good but they aren’t getting younger. Especially at the tackle position.
61. Jacksonville Jaguars – Jerome Baker, OLB, Ohio State: Jacksonville may need a young LB to replace Paul Posluszny who recently retired.
62. Minnesota Vikings – Sam Hubbard, DE, Ohio State: You can never have enough pass rushers.
63. Dallas Cowboys – Nyheim Hines, RB, NC State: This could be a reach but Dallas needs to think about the RB position after the retirement of Darren McFadden and Alfred Morris was not resigned. Hines is a speedy back who could develop into a Darren Sproles type player.
64. Cleveland Browns – James Washington, WR, Oklahoma State: Washington was regarded as one of the top pass catchers in the nation while at Oklahoma State. He could provide whoever is at QB with a pretty reliable target.